vote up 1 vote down
star

We found out recently that the subdivision we were looking to buy in is going to have a large retail complex directly next to it. One of the anchors will be a Walmart Supercenter.

A couple of properties in particular will be directly against the retail property.

Thinking that at best this makes living there a huge wild card, we did a little research and ran across this recent paper: The NWIMBY Effect (No WalMart In My Backyard): Big Box Stores and Residential Property Values. There is a bit of an effect for having Walmart so close: longer sale times for properties, and a price penalty of a few thousand dollars.

But buying and selling the property is just part of the experience, and the paper doesn't even really touch on the costs of living there.

Any insights or references? Thanks!

flag

3 Answers

vote up 1 vote down
check

I co-own a house whose neighborhood is almost adjacent to a Walmart, which shares a run-down shopping center with a Target and a Costco. The house isn't close enough to be directly affected, but it is worth mentioning that as the shopping center has slipped (it once was the city's nicest centrally located mall, housing a Bullock's and a Dillard's), the surrounding residential areas have not been helped.

Slightly tangentially: friends owned a house that backed onto a large, downscale supermarket. When the couple had a new house built at the top of the bubble, they ill-advisedly decided not to sell while before the developer completed the construction. Their new place wasn't finished until after the real estate market collapsed, and so when time came to move, they were stuck with two houses. Though houses a block or two away from the store sold (sooner or later), they could not sell theirs. After two or three years of struggling to sell it and keep it rented (no, renters don't want to live next to a grocery store where wee-hours garbage collection sounds like a wrecking yard and the homeless mentally ill camping in the parking lot throw garbage and human waste over the wall into the backyard at night), they finally were forced to default. The bank hasn't been able to sell the place, either.

Walmart, because of the nature of its clientele, has no motivation to upgrade a shopping center. They want a scruffy, low-rent effect: that helps attract people looking for rock-bottom prices. As for nearby housing: lie down with a dog and you get up with fleas.

link|flag
vote up 1 vote down

MB, I think there are two parts to the decision-financial, and quality of life.

  • Financial:Pro-Close enough to walk? May appeal in the future to older people, and even everyone if energy prices continue to go up-which seems inevitable, with cap and trade around the corner. Con-Generally, transition zones between commercial and residential do take a hit regarding property values. As we discussed before though, if you get a great buy going in, you can mitigate that risk.
  • Quality of life: Pro-walking distance to shopping may save you time/energy. Con-Noise level, traffic, light pollution if they stay open 24 hours, which most seem to do. You haven't mentioned kids-having young kids that close to commercial would bother me, but I live in a semi-rural area.

We live on 6 acres, close to town, but not walking distance to shopping-however I do bike commute when the weather is good. So I can see the pluses to living closer to commercial options-especially as I get older.

link|flag
vote up 1 vote down

I would like to say that the close enough to walk factor would work for me. I refuse to shop at Walmart because their parking lots cause me great stress and anxiety. (and I've tried this at their stores all over the country and there is always chaos. If I absolutely have to go, I am in the space super far from the store, practically a mile away just so I don't have to deal with it.)

However, I would think that the traffic would be frustrating. I'm about five minutes from our local Walmart. I like it over there. Any closer would bring the crazy drivers too close.

link|flag
As a physician, I frequently recommend parking away from the store, for a lot of folks, that is their only exercise... – Dr Dean Nov 22 at 16:56
Understandable. I would need a walmart related xanax rx if I didn't park as far away as possible. And that's probably not good with my currently klonipin rx. :) – Frugallawyer Nov 23 at 2:57

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.